If you are currently on the diet bandwagon or about to embark on a new diet, you may be overwhelmed by the multitude of diets available to today's weight-conscious consumer. We have all heard of diet programs that have been in existence for decades such as Jenny Craig and Weight Watchers. But what about the all of other dieting concepts that so many celebrities are participating in such as the Zone, South Beach, and Atkins? I am going to cut through the thick of it and give you the skinny on these three popular dieting trends to help you determine which diet is appropriate for you.
The South Beach Diet
Former United States president and first lady Bill and Hilary Clinton both
found success with the South Beach Diet. So what does it entail?
The Phases of South Beach
To gain an understanding of how this diet program works, we must first
address the phases.
Kick-Starting Your Weight Loss
During phase one (a period of 14 days) you are permitted meat (i.e. chicken,
turkey, fish, and fish), eggs, cheese, nuts, salads (with olive oil dressing
only) and vegetables. You are encouraged to eat three meals a day and to indulge
in snacking mid-morning and mid-afternoon.
Sounds good to me! But wait, we have yet to tackle the list of foods that are
taboo to partake in. This list of forbidden items includes fruit (interesting, I
thought fruit was healthy but apparently it contains carbohydrates), bread,
rice, potatoes, and foods that are obviously unhealthy such as candy, cakes,
cookies, and ice cream. Absolutely no sugar is permissible, nor is any type of
alcohol (puts a damper on the weekend party). Fortunately, all of this
eradication is not indefinite because then along comes phase two.
Reintroducing the Right Carbs
The basic objective of phase one was to rid you of the cravings for sweets
and carbohydrates. In phase two you should still shed pounds even though you are
now permitted to eat some carbohydrates. You are still on the diet, but if you
have an occasional craving for a particular food such as chocolate or a dinner
roll, you are now allowed to have it—in moderation of course. For example, you
cannot eat a piece of chocolate and a roll in one setting. Baby steps, my
friends, baby steps.
A Diet for Life
This is the infinite phase of the diet. At this point, the South Beach claim
is that if you diligently followed the diet, you have eliminated the desire to
eat unhealthy foods, whereby making South Beach no longer a diet but more of a
lifestyle change.
The Atkins Diet
The Atkins diet has actually been around for the past three decades, but only
in recent years has it jumped to the forefront of all diets. Celebrities linked
to Atkins such as Jennifer Aniston and Nick Lachey have helped propel it to its
popular status. Also, clever marketing of Atkins brand products in stores
everywhere and many restaurants offering "Atkins-friendly" menu choices have
done nothing but fuel its notoriety. So what is all of the buzz about?
The Principles of Atkins
Atkins is driven by four basic principles: weight loss, weight maintenance,
good health, and disease prevention.
Weight Loss
Weight loss is achieved through the burning of both carbohydrates and fat as
fuel for the body\'s energy needs. Carbohydrate is the initial fuel to be
metabolized. However, when you drastically reduce the amount of carbohydrate
consumption (no carbs or sugar allowed in the initial phase of this diet so be
prepared to munch on nothing but meats—no processed meats like bacon or ham—some
cheeses, and some veggies), your body transitions from the metabolic outlet of
burning carbohydrates to burning fat as its primary energy source. This results
in weight loss.
Weight Maintenance
For each person there exists a tightly regulated carbohydrate threshold below
which fat burning and weight loss occurs. If your carbohydrate consumption
exceeds this threshold, carbohydrate burning is more prevalent and fat is
allowed to accumulate, resulting in unwanted weight gain. Each person also has a
level of carbohydrate that is a neutral point whereas he/she will neither gain
nor lose weight.
Good Health
Individuals pursuing a personalized, restricted carbohydrate nutritional
approach that includes foods rich in nutrients are more prone to meet their
nutritional needs and encourage good health than individuals pursuing low-fat,
calorie-restricted diets. Regular exercise is also a necessity for maintaining
weight, toning muscles and maintaining a sense of well-being.
Disease Prevention
By pursuing a personalized controlled carbohydrate nutritional approach that
both lowers carbohydrate intake and insulin production, people who are at high
risk for or diagnosed with chronic diseases can see improvement in clinical
parameters.
The Zone Diet
Even though the Zone diet originated twenty years ago, I had never heard a
word about it until reports surfaced that Renee Zellweger utilized it as her
tool for shedding the pounds gained for her role as Bridget Jones in the Bridget
Jones\' Diary films. What is the Zone Diet? How does it work?
The Zone Diet Concept
This diet actually originated 20 years ago. It was initially developed for
treating heart disease in Type II diabetes patients. Its basic objective is to
stabilize insulin level within the body by treating food like a drug.
It is not a high protein, low carbohydrate diet, and there are no phases to
trudge through. In fact, the foundation of this diet is carbohydrates, primarily
attained through fruits and vegetables. The recommendation is 10-15 servings of
fruits and vegetables a day, over three times the amount recommended by the
United States government.
Protein is supplemented through meat servings; rule-of-thumb is meat should
not exceed palm-size.
The Zone diet uses the dietary principles 40,30,30 as
a guide to preparing each Zone diet meal or snack-40% carbohydrates, 30% fat,
and 30% protein. The precise amount differs for each person depending on your
activity levels etc.
All in All
Obviously, each of these diets, if followed closely, proves effective as
there are living testimonies everywhere singing their praises. However, the more
research I performed for each program, the more I discovered how similar they
really are. Each diet not only addresses weight issues but also health issues in
general. And as with any diet, they each have the potential for major regression
and disappointment if not diligently followed. So now it is up to you to decide
which end of the bandwagon you wish to jump on. Good luck!