Sexual harassment in the workplace creates an environment that demeans the victims and has a negative impact on individual performance and effectiveness as well as organizational productivity and unit morale.
Kate, a trainee copywriter with an advertising agency, was sitting at her
computer punching keys. Suddenly she felt a pair of hands on her shoulders. As
she looked up, she saw her senior standing right behind her, rubbing the nape
of her neck with his thumbs. Before she could say anything, he started reading
aloud. Even though she felt uncomfortable, she mutely listened to her copy
being read in a tone that was slowly taking a sarcastic edge. “This kind of
copy just won’t do, Miss Kate”, declared her boss. And this was not the first
time that Kate had to endure the touch or the barbs.
Say, what the heck! Isn’t this a common sight in any workplace? But hold! If
it had made Kate uncomfortable, it wasn’t innocent and may well constitute
sexual harassment. Now, wasn’t sexual harassment supposed to mean that you have
to perform sexual favors in order to get a promotion or hold on to your job?
No. And it is important for all employees to know that the law protects them
from all kinds of inappropriate touches, suggestions and other more subtle
sexual innuendoes.
Defining sexual harassment
Sexual harassment at workplace is a universal occurrence. It can occur in a
variety of situations. In the U.S.,
sexual harassment is considered a form of discrimination that violates ‘Title
VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964’. According to this Act, sexual harassment
occurs when one employee makes continued, unwelcome sexual advances, requests
for sexual favors, and other verbal or physical conduct of a sexual nature, to
another employee, against his or her wishes.
According to Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, sexual harassment
occurs "when submission to or rejection of this conduct explicitly or
implicitly affects an individual's employment, unreasonably interferes with an
individual's work performance or creates an intimidating, hostile or offensive
work environment."
What’s more, a 1998 Supreme Court judgment has made employers more liable
for incidents of sexual harassment. According to the Supreme Court an employer
is responsible for the actions of his or her supervisor, even when the employer
is unaware of the supervisor’s behavior. The employers can no longer claim that
they did not know about the sexual harassment because the employee did not
inform them, nor can they claim that they were unaware of the supervisor’s
behavior.
Sexual harassment – Is it really a workplace problem?
Yes it is. Trauma caused by sexual harassment can be extreme. It may result
in humiliation, loss of dignity, psychological and, sometimes, physical injury,
and damage to professional reputation and career. Inevitably, the victims face
a choice between their work and their self-esteem. Sometimes, they face a
choice between their jobs and their own safety.
Studies have shown that 40 to 70 percent of women and 10 to 20 percent of
men have been the target of sexual harassment in the workplace. If numbers are
anything to go by, approximately fifteen thousand sexual harassment cases are
brought to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission each year!
A telephone poll conducted by Louis Harris and Associates on 782 workers
revealed that a total of 31 percent women and 7 percent men claimed to have
been sexually harassed at work. Almost 100 percent women claimed the harasser
to be a man, of which 43 percent pointed the finger at the supervisor, 27
percent at a senior employee, 19 at the coworker and 8 percent at a junior
employee (now that’s real cheek!). In the case of men, 59 percent claimed the
harasser to be a woman and 41 percent, another man. But the most alarming fact was
that 62 percent of these sexually harassed people took just no action against
their perpetrators!
A study conducted by the U.S. Merit Systems Protection Board in 1988
concluded that sexual harassment, resulting in sick leave and job turnover, had
cost the federal government a whopping 267.3 million dollars in lost
productivity, in just over two years!
Types and forms of sexual harassment
The law recognizes two kinds of sexual harassment in the workplace,
"quid-pro-quo" and "hostile environment".
·
Quid-pro-quo, Latin for "this for
that" indicates a trade. In our context, the offender offers a job benefit
in return for sex. For example, if Kate’s senior had asked her to sleep with
him in return for job confirmation, it would constitute sexual harassment, akin
to the "casting couch". This kind of sexual harassment can be
negative too. For example, "sleep with me or you're fired".
·
Hostile environment sexual harassment is a
situation in which the offender does or says things that make the employee feel
uncomfortable because of his or her sex. This kind of sexual harassment is
different from a demand for sex for a job benefit, but may create the
circumstances for it.
Sexual harassment can take various forms that may involve:
Staring, ogling or leering.
Showing unnecessary
familiarity.
Making suggestive comments or
cracking vulgar jokes.
Asking personal questions
about the victim’s private life.
Heaping sex-based insults or
taunts.
Sending sexually explicit
emails or SMS messages.
Deliberately accessing sexually
explicit Internet sites in the presence of the victim.
Displaying sexually explicit
pictures, screen savers or posters.
Proposing unwanted dates or
making requests for sex.
Inappropriate touching,
hugging or kissing.
Criminal behavior like obscene
communication, stalking, indecent exposure, molestation, and physical or
sexual assault.
For an act to constitute a sexual harassment, it should be unwelcome. Even
once is enough for it to become a sexual harassment. It must be of a sexual
nature. And it should constitute behavior that would offend, humiliate or
intimidate the victim.
However, it is good to remember that sexual harassment is different from
sexual interaction or light flirtation, which is consensual and based on mutual
attraction or friendship, and is certainly not unwelcome! For, without office
romance things may become rather dull in the workplace and gossip mills may
even grind to a halt!
Important facts and circumstances that employees should know
Employees would do well to keep the following facts and circumstances in
mind:
It is not necessary that the
perpetrators and the victims need to be men and women to constitute sexual
harassment, they can, very well, be of the same sex.
Any individual, like manager,
supervisor, coworker, supplier, customer, or anyone, who is connected to
the employee's work environment, can be the harasser.
The employee who undergoes
harassment is not the only victim, it can be all others who witness or
learn about the harassment. In other words, anyone who is affected by the
conduct can potentially complain of sexual harassment.
A victim can institute
charges even if he or she is unable to demonstrate any adverse affect on
employment, including transfers, demotions, salary cuts, and so on.
When confronted with sexual
harassment, it is best to follow the system of complaint and recommended
procedures, as spelled out in the organization’s sexual harassment policy.
Dealing with sexual harassment at workplace
Kate would have done herself a favor had she been assertive enough to tell
her senior to lay off. But, she was too timid and career conscious to put a
stop to her harassment. If ever you get into such a situation, follow the steps
given below to keep your peace of mind and career intact:
The first time you experience
harassment, request the offender to keep his hands, or his comments or
suggestions to himself. Don’t let him or her get away with it, as there is
every chance of the offender getting bolder.
Be very firm and clear in
stating that you find his or her actions offensive.
Irrespective of the
offender’s response, document everything that takes place. This should
include the date and time of the offense, as well as the details about
what happened.
Preserve as evidence all
emails or notes that ask for sexual favors or draw attention to some
inappropriate Web site or take some other written form.
If the harasser remains
undeterred, your next step should be to take action as per the guidelines
of the organization's sexual harassment policy.
Organization’s responsibility
A 1999 survey by the Society for Human Resource Management found out that 97
percent of companies have a written sexual harassment policy and 62 percent
offer sexual harassment prevention training programs. Every organization that
has a policy on sexual harassment should emphasize that such an act won’t be
tolerated and will be investigated.
The law directs that whenever someone complains of sexual harassment, an
immediate investigation of the charge should occur. The employer has a legal
and ethical obligation to take each complaint seriously and thoroughly
investigate the charges. An organization, having a sexual harassment policy in
place, generally goes about the complaint in the following way:
As soon as a complaint of sexual harassment is
received, the employer assures the victim that reporting the incident was his
or her most appropriate action and that he or she is safe from retaliation.
Assigns a staff member to the case, who is
knowledgeable about the organization and its employees.
Asks the victim to
immediately inform if he or she experiences any retaliation, threat or
continued harassment from the accused directly, or indirectly through
someone else.
Encourages the victim to tell the whole story in
his or her own words. Listens and takes down the details, such as dates, times,
situations, witnesses, and anything else that seems relevant.
Informs the accused about the complaint and
warns him or her against indulging in retaliation or unethical actions.
Assures both the victim and the accused of a
fair and just investigation.
Chalks out a plan to investigate and interview
the accused and any potential witnesses by asking open-ended questions that
seek to support or disprove the victim’s allegations.
Having completed the investigation, takes a
decision on whether sexual harassment occurred or not. For arriving at this
decision, the investigator may consult other colleagues too.
On the basis of the findings, takes disciplinary
action against the offender, as spelled out in the company’s policy. To prevent
further harassment, adjusts working situations fairly and in such a way that it
is comfortable and productive for all.
Files the case and ensures that no further
incidents of this nature occur.
Having said this, it is important to state that no situation can be
perfectly investigated. Even when harassment may have occurred, there may be no
facts or witnesses that corroborate a victim’s statement. If the victim is not
entirely satisfied about the investigation, he or she also has the option of
obtaining legal counseling outside the workplace. However, this may entail
finding out about individual state guidelines and the remedies under the civil
law.
It may also be of advantage to know that the Supreme Court has given an opportunity
to the employers for defending themselves against a sexual harassment lawsuit.
The employers only need to show that they took reasonable care to prevent and
correct any sexual harassment behavior within the workplace, and that the
employee unreasonably failed to take advantage of any preventive or corrective
opportunities provided by them. So, be sure about your actions before you get
involved in litigation against the organization or it may prove even more
harassing than the sexual harassment itself!
How organizations can prevent lawsuits
The following actions may help organizations from being slapped with sexual
harassment lawsuits:
Draw up a sexual
harassment/discrimination policy quickly, if you don’t have one already.
Get it vetted by an attorney and make all your employees read and sign it.
It should proclaim that your organization does not, in any way, tolerate
sexual harassment. Update this policy annually.
Make employees and
supervisors aware of the contents of the policy from time to time and
drive home the point that reporting would not go against the employee
alleging sexual harassment. Ask the supervisors to immediately inform the
management of all sexual harassment complaints, without exception.
Provide different avenues for
employees to file complaints like installing a hotline, approaching the HR
department or contacting especially designated supervisors. Give the
option of both male and female company representatives.
Encourage employees to come
forward and report sexual harassment that they experience or witness.
Conduct sexual harassment
training, even if it only constitutes reading material or an audio-video
presentation. With this, your employees cannot claim that they were not
provided training.
Undertake annual survey by
asking the employees whether they have experienced any form of sexual
harassment during the past year. This will show how serious and proactive
your organization is in preventing and correcting sexual harassment. This
will also help pre-empt potential sexual harassment violations before they
become a problem.
Conduct proper and thorough
investigations of the complaints received and ensure that the victims
don’t suffer any retaliation. Treat same-sex harassment at par with those
of the opposite sex.
Keep a record of all cases
and the methods instituted for the correction and prevention of sexual
harassment.
In conclusion, don’t ignore a sexual harassment situation by assuming it
will stop on its own. This may not only give wrong signals to the offender, but
may also put others in the workplace at risk. The best defense for the
employees is to understand their rights and confront the offender with
confidence and conviction.